Tuesday, Apr 30 2024 | Updated at 04:56 AM EDT

Stay Connected With Us F T R

Oct 07, 2019 10:36 AM EDT


Back in October 2018, Harvard University faced a lawsuit involving its undergraduate admission processes and policies. The said case has resulted in the Ivy League school being pitted against Students for Fair Admissions (SFFA), an organization created by conservative activist Edward Blum. The group opposes affirmative action policies in an effort to include the minority groups which have been historically neglected or marginalized because of discrimination.

In general, the College has been accused of racial bias against Asian-American students and applicants. The formal complaint revolves around the College's admission practices and policies, focused on what SFFA sees as an apparent injustice towards the screening process for applicants of Asian descent.

"At issue is whether the College's "holistic" admissions practices-which evaluate students not only for grades and test scores, but also for personal traits such as character-discriminate against Asian-American applicants," explained by Harvard Magazine.

SFFA claims that Harvard University discriminates against Asian-American applicants since they set a higher bar for applicants of Asian descent before they are accepted into the College. The group also highlighted that the institution uses a quota system that limits the number of Asian students on campus to make space for other racial groups. They referred to this process as racial balancing, a system that is tagged as illegal under the Federal Law.

Because of these claims, Harvard University's policies, practices, and traditions were thrown under public scrutiny. Despite the case mainly challenging the ostensible accusations of unjust admission processes, SFFA brought attention to other traditions and policies of the College as well. This includes policies involving athletes, children of donors, and alumni.

Faced with these allegations, Harvard University remained firm in its stand. The College claimed that they use a "holistic" strategy to evaluate all applicants. They issued a statement saying that race is only a minor consideration when it comes to admitting students on campus. They do, however, evaluate through test scores, grades, and personal traits - a term that was misunderstood in this case for it refers to the character of the applicant. It was also pointed out that the College's admission policies and practices received careful examination before they were implemented, ensuring that the Law is truly upheld.

In addition, the institution emphasized that the number of Asian students enrolled in the College has been steadily increasing over the past few years. It was revealed that 23% of the entire student body's population on campus now consists of Asian students.

Fortunately for the Ivy League school, US District Judge Allison Burroughs ruled in favor of Harvard University against the allegations of racial bias on Asian-American applicants. The federal judge pointed out that Harvard's programs and policies are far from perfect, but are constitutional at the very least.

"The court will not dismantle a very fine admissions program that passes constitutional muster, solely because it could do better," she wrote in her decision, which was released October 2, 2019 as reported by BBC News. The case has been put on a non-jury trial for almost a year before the decision has been given.

With the result of the case being in favor of Harvard University, SFFA is expected to appeal the decision; however, the group has not issued a response as of writing. Nonetheless, if they so choose to appeal, the case is expected to end up in the Supreme Court.

Related Article: Tommy Lee Jones Was A Harvard Graduate Before He Was A Man In Black

See Now: Covert Team Inside Newsweek Revealed as Key Players in False Human Trafficking Lawsuit

© 2024 University Herald, All rights reserved. Do not reproduce without permission.

Must Read

Common Challenges for College Students: How to Overcome Them

Oct 17, 2022 PM EDTFor most people, college is a phenomenal experience. However, while higher education offers benefits, it can also come with a number of challenges to ...

Top 5 Best Resources for Math Students

Oct 17, 2022 AM EDTMath is a subject that needs to be tackled differently than any other class, so you'll need the right tools and resources to master it. So here are 5 ...

Why Taking a DNA Test is Vital Before Starting a Family

Oct 12, 2022 PM EDTIf you're considering starting a family, this is an exciting time! There are no doubt a million things running through your head right now, from ...

By Enabling The Use Of Second-Hand Technology, Alloallo Scutter It's Growth While Being Economically And Environmentally Friendly.

Oct 11, 2022 PM EDTBrands are being forced to prioritise customer lifetime value and foster brand loyalty as return on advertising investment plummets. Several brands, ...