Monday, May 06 2024 | Updated at 09:21 AM EDT

Stay Connected With Us F T R

Apr 22, 2014 11:54 AM EDT

A state law banning affirmative action in public college admissions survived a Supreme Court challenge, Inside Higher Ed reported. The challenge was specifically directed towards a Michigan law passed in 2006, but, if successful, would have impacted a host of similar state laws around the country, including those in California and Washington State.

Justice Anthony Kennedy, Chief Justice John Roberts, and Justice Samuel Alito ruled in favor of Michigan's current law because they did not feel its intent was racist and it provided alternative pathways to admit more minority students (rather than allowing colleges to make exceptions based on race).

"The question here, as in every case in which neutral state action is said to deny equal protection on account of race, is whether the challenged action reflects a racially discriminatory purpose. It plainly does not," the three judges said.

The justices explained that the purpose of the ruling was not to judge the constitutionality of affirmative action in college admissions, but to judge the constitutionality of a state's right to decide how best to tackle the issue of racial diversity in higher education. In the process, they determined that states were allowed to reject certain considerations when it comes to race.

"This case is not about the constitutionality, or the merits, of race-conscious admissions policies in higher education. Here, the principle that the consideration of race in admissions is permissible when certain conditions are met is not being challenged," the justices wrote. "Rather, the question concerns whether, and in what manner, voters in the states may choose to prohibit the consideration of such racial preferences. Where states have prohibited race-conscious admissions policies, universities have responded by experimenting with a wide variety of alternative approaches. The decision by Michigan voters reflects the ongoing national dialogue about such practices." 

See Now: Covert Team Inside Newsweek Revealed as Key Players in False Human Trafficking Lawsuit

© 2024 University Herald, All rights reserved. Do not reproduce without permission.

Must Read

Common Challenges for College Students: How to Overcome Them

Oct 17, 2022 PM EDTFor most people, college is a phenomenal experience. However, while higher education offers benefits, it can also come with a number of challenges to ...

Top 5 Best Resources for Math Students

Oct 17, 2022 AM EDTMath is a subject that needs to be tackled differently than any other class, so you'll need the right tools and resources to master it. So here are 5 ...

Why Taking a DNA Test is Vital Before Starting a Family

Oct 12, 2022 PM EDTIf you're considering starting a family, this is an exciting time! There are no doubt a million things running through your head right now, from ...

By Enabling The Use Of Second-Hand Technology, Alloallo Scutter It's Growth While Being Economically And Environmentally Friendly.

Oct 11, 2022 PM EDTBrands are being forced to prioritise customer lifetime value and foster brand loyalty as return on advertising investment plummets. Several brands, ...