Saturday, Apr 27 2024 | Updated at 08:47 AM EDT

Stay Connected With Us F T R

Oct 08, 2013 11:08 AM EDT

Is prestige or the public agenda better for a state university and its student body? 

An increasing number of state universities are negotiating the line between public and private by cutting deals with state lawmakers to break away from the state network. The results so far appear mostly positive for the schools and mixed for the public, The Huffington Post reported.

Schools leave the state system in search of greater autonomy, according to The Huffington Post. Though many lose some state funding, universities benefit from fewer restrictions via reduced state-mandated performance targets and more financial freedom, including the ability to raise tuition. With state funding decreasing anyway, the freedom to increase tuition can significantly help a university.

The most recent institutions to break away from their state systems are the University of Oregon, Portland State University and Oregon State University, according to The Huff Post. Schools in Texas, Florida, and Virginia achieved similar goals by receiving permission to raise tuition, reported The Huff Post.

Some involved in higher education worry that schools may lose sight of the public agenda.

"My fear is that if public flagships become so focused on revenue and prestige, and so focused on autonomy, they will minimize their commitment to the public agenda," Richard Novak, former director of public-sector programs at the Association of Governing Boards, told the Huffington Post. "They should be leading the public agenda. If they privatize too much, they're not going to be doing it for much longer."

Robert O'Neil, who used to head the University of Wisconsin system and is the former president of the University of Virginia, fears universities will focus too much on public rankings and may not manage their resources efficiently without public oversight, according to The Huff Post.

"I think there's a potential for confusion, unhealthy competition and misuse of resources," O'Neil said.

Though there isn't extensive research proving either side, some trends have emerged supporting the views of Novak and O'Neil. According to The Huff Post, universities with greater autonomy have seemed to increase tuition while offering big aid packages to coveted students. Pro Publica reported that such schools have given more aid to higher income students and less to students in need.

If you're a student at a college like the University of Virginia, which struck a deal for greater autonomy in 2005, you could be benefitting from the increased revenue via better funded programs, new tech centers, or nicer athletic facilities. James Garland, former president of Miami University who once supported the notion of privatization within public schools, doesn't agree. 

"Some of these flagships would like to make decisions that benefit their own financial future and give them the ability to build posh dining halls or giant stadiums or create new nanotechnology centers," Garland said. "When what really may be more needed than that is simply providing a high-quality rigorous college education for legions of students in the state who can't afford that now and have no place to go and get it."

"It's not an accident that you see this happening among big, well-funded publics," he added.

See Now: Covert Team Inside Newsweek Revealed as Key Players in False Human Trafficking Lawsuit

© 2024 University Herald, All rights reserved. Do not reproduce without permission.

Must Read

Common Challenges for College Students: How to Overcome Them

Oct 17, 2022 PM EDTFor most people, college is a phenomenal experience. However, while higher education offers benefits, it can also come with a number of challenges to ...

Top 5 Best Resources for Math Students

Oct 17, 2022 AM EDTMath is a subject that needs to be tackled differently than any other class, so you'll need the right tools and resources to master it. So here are 5 ...

Why Taking a DNA Test is Vital Before Starting a Family

Oct 12, 2022 PM EDTIf you're considering starting a family, this is an exciting time! There are no doubt a million things running through your head right now, from ...

By Enabling The Use Of Second-Hand Technology, Alloallo Scutter It's Growth While Being Economically And Environmentally Friendly.

Oct 11, 2022 PM EDTBrands are being forced to prioritise customer lifetime value and foster brand loyalty as return on advertising investment plummets. Several brands, ...